Heart Cakes Near Me in NYC


City Cakes’ breathtaking and exquisitely designed heart cakes will undoubtedly leave an impression, yet these creations come at a higher cost than you might expect.

Milk Bar’s iconic birthday cake has long been one of the city’s signature sweets; nearly every New Yorker who has lived here long enough has either tasted it themselves or received one as a present.

Magnolia Bakery

Magnolia Bakery is an iconic New York bakery known for its irresistible cupcakes, classic old-fashioned banana pudding, and alluring cakes. Their desserts make a tempting treat on any special occasion and feature-rich, flavorful desserts with visually striking displays. In addition, Magnolia offers delicious savory options like sandwiches and quiches, which complement its sweet offerings perfectly.

Decades-old recipes make their cookies irresistibly delectable – from traditional chocolate chip to comforting oatmeal raisin varieties! Additionally, there is an exquisite array of irresistible cakes, including seasonal specialties and custom-designed tiers for weddings or milestone anniversaries.

The bakery is an iconic West Village institution and widely celebrated as such with appearances on Sex and the City and Saturday Night Live, not to mention being credited with starting the cupcake craze – with famous cupcakes like Brooklyn Blackout made of chocolate cake, banana pudding, and fudge frosting and Carrie Cupcake featuring natural sea salt on top!

Magnolia features many fun flavors, like Pretzel and Beer, which are made with pale ale, Nutella, and pretzel. Their two-woman bakery provides the ideal place for a sugar rush; their cupcakes and cakes can even come with customized packaging featuring your company logo or message on them for corporate events! Indulge yourself today at Magnolia!

Flour Shop

Flour Shop, led by former art gallerist Eunji Lee, creates cakes inspired by still lifes and the inimitable atmosphere of the fine arts world. Although its high-end individual-sized bakes (the most petite cake costs $150 and feeds 15 people) are, the atmosphere here remains welcoming; many cakes draw their inspiration from famous fine artists; some feature Eunji Lee’s uncanny ability, as demonstrated by Corn, their most beloved creation that looks just like natural corn on the cob.

City Cakes has long been known for its striking fondant creations. At City Cakes, almost anything can be transformed into a cake at an exorbitant cost; for those seeking something simpler with less extravagant design elements, they offer cupcakes and single slices as options.

This bakery is the premier source for gluten-free, vegan, dairy-free, or kosher cakes and baked treats such as cookies, brownies, pastries, and bread – perfect for wedding cakes and corporate events alike! All their products are produced in-house using only premium quality ingredients.


Heart-shaped cakes are an adorable way to show your affection. From birthdays, Valentine’s Day, and Galentine’s Day all the way through Galentine’s day! Choose from our variety of flavors and customize it with a personal message on top – our tri-state delivery option makes the cake easy.

While showpiece cakes remain the centerpiece of New York City’s bakery scene, innovative shops like Baked have begun catering to demand for smaller portions. Their brownies have gained widespread fame thanks to celebrities like Oprah Winfrey, who sing their praises.

Although one slice may seem minor in terms of cake consumption, its impact has been profound. Consumers now demand high-quality treats outside celebratory settings, and From Lucy often sells out its small cakes and slices by 1:30 p.m. The bakery offers Black Sesame and Passion Fruit Entremet, Strawberry Yuzu Mille Crepe Cake and other baked goods that highlight its signature approach to baking where French technique meets Japanese flavor.

Erin McKenna’s Bakery

At this bakery, they provide delicious dairy-, gluten-, egg- and soy-free treats made with quality ingredients – making them healthy choices for those with food allergies or those looking to reduce processed sugar consumption. Their friendly staff makes their experience truly pleasant!

Erin McKenna’s Bakery (previously BabyCakes) takes steps to ensure everyone can enjoy the delicious sweet treats they crave – the menu at their bakery is kosher, while all baked goods are vegan, gluten-free, refined sugar-free, wheat-free, soy-free, and nut-free!

Erin McKenna offers a vast array of baked goods, such as muffins, cookies, eclairs, breads, and cinnamon rolls, as well as beverages to choose from. Not only is Erin McKenna an ideal place for those with dietary restrictions to visit, but it is also perfect for anyone who loves cake! They even sell cookbooks as the ideal present for anyone interested in gluten-free baking who would like to learn how to create their treats from home; their prices are very affordable as well! So, if you want something genuinely unforgettable this holiday season, think about purchasing Erin McKenna’s cookbook today – it won’t disappoint!

Amy’s Bread

Since 1992, Amy’s Bread has quickly become one of the world’s premier bakeries. Their signature baked goods feature natural and wholesome ingredients and can be shipped nationwide; additionally, Amy’s Bread also provides sandwiches, salads, desserts (especially cakes!), sandwiches, and salads, as well as its cozy atmosphere located within Chelsea Market.

This bakery is beloved among both New Yorkers and visitors, winning numerous culinary industry accolades such as Crain’s “40 Under 40” Rising Stars in Business award in 1997 and New York City Women’s Small Business Owner of the Year award in 1999. Additionally, it was featured in numerous publications like Time Out New York magazine and Gourmet magazine.

Since 1992, this bakery has been a favorite among locals since its opening. Renowned for their heart-shaped loaves, they also sell other baked goods and boast a lovely back seating area for customers to relax while they enjoy their pastries or coffee. Plus, LGBT-friendly and accommodating staff makes this shop perfect for finding delicious treats!

Rob Ben-Israel Cakes

Rob Ben-Israel Cakes is one of the world’s premier couture cake studios, renowned for its inventive and exquisite creations. Established by Ron Ben-Israel in 1999 in Manhattan’s trendy SoHo neighborhood, this flagship design studio and bakery moved to a larger facility in the Garment District at the end of 2014.

His cakes have been showcased in books, magazines, films, and TV shows alike; he even served as a judge on Food Network’s Sweet Genius and Cake Wars competitions! With an exquisite style and technique all his own, his cakes have won him admiration among wedding planners as well as celebrities alike.

He specializes in designing exquisite, one-of-a-kind cakes for weddings and other special events, featuring elegant yet tasteful designs with clean lines and memorable flavors. Additionally, they provide an array of fondant shapes and colors to accommodate any theme or event.

This gorgeous heart-shaped cake makes a fantastic Valentine’s Day or birthday treat, and you can even include your custom message or quote to make it extra special! Please be aware that any additional design requests will incur a further price increase; delivery to NYC addresses only.

Soma Cakes

Soma Cakes of Brooklyn offers customized cakes for special events. Their talented bakers collaborate with clients to design wedding cakes, cupcakes, and macaron towers, as well as dessert buffets to meet any client request.

Hiroyo Kuramata, the shop’s owner and custom cake designer, has gained international acclaim as an experienced pastry technician and innovative innovator, working alongside some of the world’s premier chefs and honing her skills while developing her signature style of baking.

Both children and adults love this Brooklyn bakery. Their chocolate-covered strawberries and Oreo mousse are particularly well-liked. Additionally, this store specializes in decorating birthday-themed cakes, which can either be picked up in store or delivered directly.

Milk Bar Bakery was the pioneer of the naked cake trend, established by Christina Tosi of Milk Bar (famous for cereal milk ice cream, compost cookies, and crack pie birthday cake). Their cake offerings range from classic designs to more whimsical creations – their signature dessert being banana pudding that perfectly blends sweet and tart flavors!